Log in with your MaiOtaku account.
Home Forum Anime Search Newest Help

Critique shit thread

personalmaidservice
Is it bad I don’t think most things are good and am afraid to say things cause I know ppl like said animes or seasonal animes in different places and some ppl will probs give me flack but I’m also don’t want them to dislike their anime even when talking to some friends (except when there waifu is trash *cough*002 *cough* rem *cough*) idk sometimes it’s hard sometimes it isn’t But critique and pointing out flaws in juxtaposition to the positives of the animes is super hard not to do and it’s hard sometimes to me to just go I like it it’s good or I dislike it it’s bad with out the why to the point where it’s the same things I feel about current movies where I notice obvious flaws which I have to bend over backwards a]to block out of my mind What animes do you think are over rated, or changed your mind about or are good despite its flaws? I’m just your avg. seasonal watcher ;p
mariahaise
Your waifu is probably trash too and I don't need to prove this since you didn't do the same with your opinion.
personalmaidservice
Jokes on you I don’t really got a waifu
mariahaise
Ah right, you said you don't really like many things, what a fulfilling life you must have.
personalmaidservice
Rem; to she’s a very boring waifu liked for big titties and easy appeal for for being a twin character often leading to yuri fan art, cosplays and all that jazz. To me she’s pretty overrated because her character is just as bland as Subaru’s himself and Emilia’s. Re:Zero was a pretty good turn off my brain anime but Rem herself was built up mostly around fandom anger due to one episode but her in previous and after episodes didn’t matte much and her level of depth is by far more from the fans then the actual show. Horny bois like Big tiddie Twincest. Also Emilia is double trash cause she has even less personality or anything for that matter but that’s a different discussion. Re;Zero for the most part wasn’t that great to me it was just okay a very pass times kinda anime and not much thought I had to put into it unless I want to get into it 002: She’s an okay waifu but the community made her trash with the twitter war and her character design is fun and sleek making for tons of fan art, But her herself also to me is pretty bland, the need to care for her isn’t really all there and the episodes that were cute that were suppose to make me care I would of had to turn of my brain for that cause everything else after as well as during was “meh: and the level of depth I was getting from her felt like any other waifu I’ve seen before. Fans making the waifu but not the actual story itself. The show itself had a good premise but went completely array and kinda slowly watered down the characters to me along with 002. Her Apeal goes as far as minor sexual tones and saying darling. Could even call it a slightly less annoying Yuno gasai on the premise of just the “darling darling darling” aspect. I felt like she could’ve been better just like the shows world, but none the less she’s just “okay Trash” with a back story that didn’t make me feel anything Other WAIFUS for that matter that are bland I know these harem animes but Saenai heroine although not the greatest narratively but at least in design and appeal were great and fun characters. Although tropey they had a feeling where they mattered even during petty times and didn’t fall off, even though I know they were built for appeal in a character driven show they didn’t feel watered down in even parts that dragged on for their character. Oregairu could kinda be said the same and also Onodera from Nisekoi could also The same issues I have with those 2 though is the same with Fairytale WAIFUS Naruto WAIFUS and things of the like the feel... “okay” “garbage” or “meh” I know WAIFUS are suppose to make me like them braindead and maybe I’ll like them if there’s some cute factor but it doesn’t prevent me from seeing things as cliche, or I expect this type of character to be popular for what ever seasonal reason Or other WAIFUS I have a problem with is like Nico or some love live shit. It’s utterly bland or some stuff thrown on the paper that I could care less about said character. It’s why I’m into waifu culture as a meme and a joke but not as some semi attachment or enough to go and praise and draw fan art for. The stories to me don’t make me feel like I should care at all and kinda feel 1 dimensional. It’s also why when a friend tried to shove 002 praises in my face and I was like she snot that great, she has a appealing character design but not much more, it’s kinda it.
marinblue
I mean hey everyone has their tastes! I mean I'm a bit of the opposite! Personally, I have trouble disliking shows unless it does something I really really dislike? I think that a lot of shows have something really going for it even if it isn't the best executed. To answer the questions well I don't really know about overrated? Personally, I think people have their reasons to enjoy a show and just because a lot of people like it, it doesn't really bring down the quality. If I don't really like it I usually just think "Well it just wasn't for me" Honestly despite flaws they might have I honestly love the subbed Transformers Unicron Trilogy. I honestly think they're misunderstood by a lot of fans due to the poor translation with the dubbing. The trilogy isn't perfect but I still really enjoy them ^^;
personalmaidservice
On the note of me not liking things, I do like things but I will admit some of the things are like are pretty trashy or poorly written. I also don’t really chose favorites either in anime. I do like a lot of generic anime, some harem anime, and some cheesy slice of life shoujo. A lot of them are very predictable sometimes terrible stories bad characters and I’m very self aware of the flaws but I still enjoy them, I never said I didn’t like a lot of things I said I find it hard to just say I like something and not give myself an internal reason why I like or dislike said something cause then it allows me if I wanna talk to somebody about it or make a joke out of said anime if it is trashy, if there trashy or bad or okay maybe I’ll rememeber them or write them down. I know I go in circles a bunch cause what I think and what I type are 2 different things, but what are you getting at with that jab of Unfuffilment??? I thought the first post y9u sent maybe might be a non serious joke in ref for me calling something trash joke but, okay.
mariahaise
Lmao you're funny, I used the same meaning to the words you typed: "I don't think most things are good". Never said you didn't like anything c:
personalmaidservice
@Marinblue Yeah I get that, usually I’m more of I like a character because of a story rather than the only acception being quirkiness and a cool character design A. Like it because it’s in B.Everyone else likes it so I must like it C. just cause sex appeal (which is fine) It’s mostly not a critique of the person who likes it but more or less the character itself with how it is stand alone. I like to genuinely be invested somewhat into characters unless they’re not built that way like shows like Monster musume where you can just enjoy a character and not worry about whether a show is shit or not Like funny enough though I Unironically enjoy generic seasonal stuff, bland Moe anime, and things like Neo Yokio
personalmaidservice
I meant to mean things are good from the standpoint of the show itself or what ever *insert anime here* maybe has some bad plot, plot holes, bad premise, bad characters. Etc. Which is different then what you said about not liking a lot of things.
Continue
Please login to post.