Do guys like otaku girls, great at drawing, smart, and talented girls (pretty too) or are they too perfect and unapproachable?

I like girls that enjoy anime as much as I do. While not that extremely rare, it is rare to find a girl much over 18 that is still heavily interested in such topics. Which is the challenge in my case. My ex actually got me more into anime and going to conventions. But she was only interested in very few anime series, she was more into gaming. Except for a few major issues between us, she was close to being my perfect type. But she was 18 and I was 32 at the time we got together. That by itself really wasn't an issue, but the older I get, the fewer girls I find who share my interests (and don't consider me too old to date).

You don't have to apologize! You don't sound narcissistic whatsoever. I just don't think you should care what guys like.

It depends on the guy really, Some are way too shy to do so and some will jump at the chance like she's a miracle sent from heaven. It really just depends, Though you can certainly believe there's plenty of both, So you shouldn't worry about it.

At some point you realize that no one is too perfect to approach. Sadly, girls gradually lost their mystique the more of them I got to know. As for intelligence, some people prefer a mate that is less intelligent than themselves. I prefer someone I can hold a conversation with. The thing is, beauty and talent are subjective. Intelligence is relative and can take more than one form. Overall I say be yourself, both the good and the bad. Try to recognize and improve the bad, but don't obsess over it. Either someone will like you for who you are, or you are better off to find someone else.