Re-0: The five royal candidates

@Senpaisamasan Well, season 2 is about to drop, and they just put out a 13 episode directors cut of season 1. So if you want to rewatch it, there's never been a better time.

After watching frozen bond i have zero doubts emilia is satella at this point. She has a power that uncontrollable, and puck's brother tried to kill her because she would bring an end to the world. Plus she looks exactly like the jealous witch. I wonder what happens when subaru makes her jealous

@hell_hound7 I think that its more like any half elf witch has the potential to become Satella. I seem to recall a certain lunatic in season one saying things like "She's a perfect vessel" and stuff. (And I also think that is the reason Puck was contracted to watch over her.) It might also be a lineage thing, where she's a family descendant. But if she is Satella, then who froze her? And who thawed her, while leaving all the rest of the elves frozen? Its still possible you're right. That's a possibility I came to as well, and have yet to rule out. But one thing is for certain. Puck made a choice, and we don't have full context on the vow he broke either. I think in breaking that vow, Puck lost memory of something very important. And that might be why Tsuburu was pulled into the other world and given whatever that authority is in the first place. Like Satella intends for him to be Puck's replacement. There's uh... Also a character (Echidna, the witch of greed according to the trailer) that is going to get a lot of screen time in the next season judging from the trailer, who looks like similar to Satella/Emilia, but if you look at her ears, she's a human, not a Half Elf. So it's possible witches in general have an uncanny resemblance to Satella. But again, only half elves have the potential to be a vessel. And I guess because of that stigma, no elf/human mating occured in thousands of years or whatever, but that may have been why she was thawed. Maybe she's from a time before the witch made half elves stigmatized. A twin sister, perhaps. Needless to say, there are still a lot of questions, and I think season 2 is only going to answer some of them.

@chocopyro hmmm very good theories. As an anime only, my guess is that puck promised not to interfere too much with emilia, but yes she could be a vessel for the witch. I feel the reason subaru was dragged into the world wasnt because he is there to help emilia he is there to be a catalyst for the witch's awakening. Hence why he cant mention his power, why she caressed his heart during the battle with the white whale. He belongs to witch and he doesnt know it. Now which witch however we dont know. I wanna see how things play out tho. There is alot we dont know like the carvings on flugel tree or what happened to the bowel hunter, or if Reinhardt is wilhelm's son. With his mother being the red headed sword girl.