Need otaku help

Here is what we have so far. Asterisk means it’s a word we need for the clue. 1 2 melon bread (this was the mistake as it contradicts with 8) 3 onigiri (Pokemon) *4 cake (ouran high school host club) 5 gumgum *6 *7 narutomaki *8 the drink of the gods *9 milk (Fma) 10 11