Pretty much all anime has the ability to make me cry, either from it being sad, too happy, sweet, you name it. Angel Beats! did make me cry too like OP, very much like a baby.
Assassination classroom T_T
No anime ever made me cry. I'm a manly man. ;o
The animes that make me cry are always the ones who have a good romance story. Especially when the mc is not sure about the relationship or ones where heart break happens.
Re-watching Plastic memories.
I already know I'm going to cry soon.
for me...every anime that ends. i always tear up at the last episodes even if its a comedy. if im into it i. will. cry.
I spent the best part of my morning watching sad and inspirational scenes from Naruto I cried all morning till I had enough
The anime that made me cry was chrono crusade.