Yeah, Durarara is definitely the more popular of the two. I liked Baccano better, though. It has such a fun cast of characters and it was nice to see an anime that wasn't set in Japan like every other one. I bet you'd enjoy it. =]

Ah, that's too bad. D: I can't blame you if they were really creepy, though. Some fandoms get like that, and some people just don't know when to stop. Say, have you seen the Baccano anime? :3

Oh, nice. You really are an ACen vet then! A friend of mine went as Rarity, too. Reminds me that I still gotta watch most of the second season of MLP:FIM. xD