Value in motion games anymore?

PS Move looks like a flop, Kinect is good only for parties and/or being lazy, and the Nintendo stuff is kinda looking like it's on its last legs. One motion game I loved playing was The Fight: Lights Out on PS3 just because it followed my boxing skills almost perfectly, better than any Kinect game or trainer could do. I'd love for any of these systems to make a 1:1 motion boxing game. Problem is that it seems the very thing they want people to do (move and interact with the game physically) is a turn-off to gamers. So does anyone here actually value any games like that, be it console or interactive as close as you can, and laser tag or anything that is not simulated (hard to get people to do that nowadays too...)? I mean, I'll turn on House of the Dead Overkill from time to time since I love shooting games like that, but still.

It had its day, like Music based games (Guitar Heroes, Rock Band, DJ Heroes, etc), DDR, etc it had its peak but now its not in that much demand.